In one of my favorite novels, The Book Thief, Nazi soldiers burn a huge stack of books because they want to protect people from harmful ideas.
In modern-day America, some groups and individuals are trying to do basically the same thing: limit access to books deemed harmful and inappropriate.
This week, the American Library Association and book lovers across the country celebrate Banned Books Week, a time set aside to raise awareness about the problem of censorship that still nags our country, even in the 21st century.
Do you believe in free access to information and ideas? Then here are five things you should know about book banning.
1. Definitions
- A challenge is an attempt to remove or restrict materials. It is more than just a person or group expressing an opinion; that group or individual wants to take away access for everyone.
- A banning is the removal of materials from a library or other point of access.
2. Reporting
The ALA compiles data based on voluntary reports of challenges or bans. It estimates that 85% of book challenges receive no media attention and are unreported.
3. Book banning can happen near you.
While browsing the ALA site, I learned that The Perks of Being a Wallflower, an excellent YA novel with a significant amount of controversial content, has been restricted in Fairfax County Virginia. I was surprised that my old school system, a large, wealthy district in the suburbs of D.C., engaged in book banning.
Also, according to an article dated October 2010, only juniors and seniors William Byrd High School and Hidden Valley High School in Roanoke, Virginia had free access to Perks. Freshmen and sophomores needed a note from a parent to check it out. I guess that’s better than pulling it all together, but I was surprised to hear about a restriction so close to my home.
4. Many well-loved and respected classics have been banned, including
- To Kill a Mockingbird
- The Great Gatsby
- The Grapes of Wrath
- The Lord of the Flies
- Of Mice and Men
- 1984
- Their Eyes Were Watching God
- The Color Purple
- Gone With the Wind
5. Institutions involved
According to the Office of Intellectual Freedom, a division of the ALA, the institutions that challenged books most often between 2000 and 2009 were schools, school libraries, and (most disturbing to me) public libraries. Individuals challenging books are most often parents.
For more statistics about book banning, check out this interesting infographic from the ALA.
The Problem
Here’s the problem with banning: Who should get to decide? One parent might want to restrict Harry Potter for its magical elements. I have no trouble with magic, but I don’t want my kids exposed to sexually explicit material. What if atheists wanted to keep C.S. Lewis novels out of schools because of their Christian themes?
We live in a free country, with many different world views affecting our choices and behavior.
Instead of banning books, teachers, librarians, and parents can encourage good reading habits and responsible thinking by:
- educating themselves and the children they work with about controversial content in books
- guiding young readers to make wise choices
- discussing controversial content in an open, constructive way
I always tell my kids that effective communication is one of the most important skills they can learn. Guess that means I’d better be ready to talk about edgy content.
Word Nerd Note: Common Sense Media is fantastic resource for finding out about controversial content in books, movies, TV and video games. It also offers discussion starters to get you through those tricky topics. I have the app on my phone, so I can get the info any time, like in the bookstore.
Giveaway
Leave a thoughtful comment below and you’ll enter a giveaway for a Barnes and Noble gift card to buy any book you choose. Even The Perks of Being a Wallflower. Just tell me what you think about book banning, if you’ve ever experienced censorship, or your ideas for handling sensitive content in books. I’d like to hear from all sides – because, as I said, good communication is key. Giveaway closes Friday, Oct 9, 2015.
More Thoughts on Banned Books

Sheila at Book Journey has links to more posts and giveaways about Banned Books on her blog. Please visit!
Thanks for adding to the discussion!
