The Pros and Cons of eReaders

The Pros and Cons of eReaders

Two summers ago, while we were on vacation in the Adirondacks, my tech-savvy friend Don sat me down with his latest gadget: an eReader.  “As much as you read, I think you’d like this,” he said as he demonstrated the e-reader’s features and quick downloading capability.  He nodded to the novel in my lap, Ken Follett’s The Pillars of the Earth, a three inch thick volume.  “This is much lighter than THAT.”

I humored him, fiddled with the buttons, saw how I could read even in the morning sunshine without worrying about glare.  But in the end, I shook my head and told him, “I like the feel of a real book in my hands.”  He glanced again at Pillars, shook his head, and then turned to my then nine-year old son.  “Okay, how about you?”

“Yeah!” my son said, eagerly grabbing the eReader.

Well, our family purchased an eReader  this year, and I’ve used it enough to see the possibilities.

eReaders eliminate bulk. 

My house has many overflowing bookshelves.  An eReader can store thousands of volumes in the space of one thin chapter book.  And as my friend Caroline pointed out, “Think of all the trees we aren’t killing!”  Since they minimize bulk, eReaders also eliminate weight; it’s much easier to travel with an eReader than multiple hardback novels and self help guides!  They are also easier to hold in bed at night (the Kindle turned my hubby into a more willing bedtime reader).

eReaders make reading more cost effective. 

With an eReader, you can sample before you buy.  Or you can sample, and then look for the book at the library!  Also, more libraries, including the one in my little town, now offer eBooks for lending through the library system to patrons with eReaders.   And lending isn’t limited to libraries.  Owners of eReaders can share books with other eReaders, and Amazon just introduced its Kindle Lending Library; Amazon Prime members can borrow one book a month from an “eLibrary” filled with present and former best sellers. 

But I still have reservations.

Sharing eBooks isn’t always easy.  There are time limits (Kindle = two weeks) and financial restrictions (most cost at least $100 and an Amazon Prime membership costs $79 per year).  According to the local librarian, a lot of the patrons she sees do not have the computer knowledge or equipment to borrow the eBooks available.   I believe everyone should have access to literature, and I worry that eReaders exclude significant segments of our population.   

My final holdout:  traditional books please the senses so much more than their digital counterparts.  I love the feel of a smooth cover, the colors and designs that reveal each book’s personality.  I like folding down corners, underlining sentences, and knowing, by thickness, how much of a book I’ve read.  I enjoy handing a favorite book to a friend and saying , “You’ve got to read THIS.” 

And, I like to take my novels into the bathtub. 

So, I think eReaders are a great option for book lovers, but they shouldn’t be the sole source of literature.

Do you agree?  Have I missed something?  Share your thoughts by clicking on “comments” below. 

Julia Tomiak
I believe in the power of words to improve our lives, and I help people find interesting words to read. Member of SCBWI.

8 Comments

  1. I’m pro about e-readers, because they are small, portable and we can take them everywhere. It’s great that when I travel I can have on it my eBooks downloaded from All you can books… a good site with many of my favorite titles. I can’t wait to have a little spare time 😀

  2. I remember the conversation like it was yesterday, and by the way did you ever finish the Pillars book??? Maybe you would have if the weight of carrying it around didn’t bring you down 🙂

    Like most things in life, everything in moderation and finding the happy balance is what is key for our enjoyment. Anything that inspires my kids or others to read is great. You know some people just take more to the electronic transmission of info.

  3. I’m with you, and you know what a tech-aholic I am. There definitely are pluses to e-readers, but there is something cozy about a REAL book.

    Maybe it’s just because it’s familiar and I’m becoming an old person who balks & gripes about change. NOooo!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.